The Orange County Register wrote:Tuesday, February 5, 2008
Sober-living house files federal complaint against Newport Beach
<span class=postbigbold>Pacific Shores Recovery says temporary ban on recovery homes is unlawful.</span>
By JEFF OVERLEY
THE ORANGE COUNTY REGISTERNEWPORT BEACH – Pacific Shores Recovery, a sober-living-home operator sued by the city last year for allegedly violating a temporary ban on recovery houses, said today that it has filed a federal complaint accusing the city of discrimination.
In the complaint, the company says no treatment or professional services are offered at the Orange Avenue sober-living home, making it exempt from the moratorium.
James Markman, a private attorney working for the city, scoffed at the lawsuit, saying rehab homes were allowed to seek exemptions from the moratorium, but none applied.
Elected leaders in April enacted a temporary ban on recovery houses, and Pacific Shores' rehab home opened afterward, according to the city lawsuit. Pacific Shores says in its complaint that the house has been open since 2004.
Before the moratorium took effect last spring, city officials said they were investigating activity at the house, which was visibly undergoing construction.
Pacific Shores attorney Steven Polin said he had no details on the construction. In any event, the moratorium, which was rescinded last month, was "plainly illegal."
"You can't enact legislation and say that a certain group of people can't live within the city," Polin said. "What would the reaction be if, instead of (recovering addicts), the moratorium was directed at racial minorities or ethnic minorities?"
Markman couldn't cite any other examples of cities in the country enacting similar moratoriums, but added that there are "not very many cities in the position that Newport Beach is in," with its estimated 80-100 recovery houses.
Such bans have been used extensively to briefly prohibit other operations, such as medical marijuana dispensaries, giving governments time to craft rules allowing them to better regulate such operations.
If the Department of Housing and Urban Development finds merit in the complaint, it could be forwarded to the Justice Department, which could level civil penalties against Newport Beach, Polin said.
Contact the writer: 714-445-6683 or
joverley@ocregister.com